The quantum world philosophical debates on quantum physics. Bernard despagnat 22 august 1921 1 august 2015 was a french theoretical physicist, philosopher of science, and author, best known for his work on the nature of reality. D espagnat investigates these questions as well as how we should answer them. Bernard despagnat, french physicist and philosopher whose research into the philosophical foundations of quantum physics addressed the conflict between the realist and instrumentalist views of the results of quantum mechanicsthat is, whether they reflect underlying physical reality or are merely.
While philosophy of science is the study of problems of knowledge concerning science in general, there also exists or should exist a philosophy in. Review of bernard despagnat, on physics and philosophy princeton. This is the basis on which bernard despagnat argues in his recent book for two philosophical claims. Concept of hypercosmic god wins templeton prize new. The debt we all owe bernard despagnat 19212015 jan. Reading a recent issue of new scientist last night, i came across a brief mention of bernard d espagnat winning this years templeton prize for arguing that quantum physics implies that reality must be partially unknowable, or veiled. Bernard d espagnat is professor emeritus of physics at the university of parisorsay, where he was director of the laboratory of theoretical physics and elementary particles from 1970 to 1987, and winner of the 2009 templeton prize. Contrary to classical physics, which was strongly objective i. In 1981, i was intrigued by the notion of veiled real by bernard despagnat 1, that did not seemed to me to be a satisfying solution to the.
These are shown to shed new light on profound questions about realism, determinism, causality or locality. The quantum theory and reality scientific american. Sought implications of quantum theory bernard despagnat being honored in 2009 for opening new vistas on the definition of reality. Pdf on physics and philosophy, bernard despagnat michael. Web despagnat reflections on books templeton prize. Apr 02, 2002 here, bernard d espagnat argues that quantum physicsby casting doubts on once hallowed concepts such as space, material objects, and causalitydemands serious reconsideration of most of here, bernard d espagnat argues that quantum physicsby casting doubts on once hallowed concepts such as space, material objects, and causalitydemands. Click download or read online button to get perspectives on quantum reality book now. Keywords amery bergson critical theory deleuze derrida fanon julia. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Knowledge, duration and the quantum world article pdf available february 1989 with 152 reads how we measure reads. He is the author of on physics and philosophy, princeton university press, 2006. Bernard d espagnat, emeritus professor at the university of paris, orsay, was born in fourmagnac, france, on august 22, 1921. Review of bernard despagnat, on physics and philosophy.
Mar 20, 2009 a lifetime studying quantum mechanics has convinced bernard d espagnat that the world we perceive is merely a shadow of the ultimate reality bernard d espagnat fri 20 mar 2009 14. On physics and philosophy, bernard despagnat request pdf. It is named for eugene wigner and bernard despagnat who as pointed out by bell both employed it in their popularizations of quantum mechanics. The authors stated aim is philosophical, but as he states at the outset. Realism and instrumentalism about the wave function. His books include the classic conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics and veiled reality. Perspectives on quantum reality download ebook pdf, epub. On physics and philosophy, bernard despagnat article in studies in history and philosophy of science part b studies in history and philosophy of modern physics 384. On physics and philosophy is an accessible, mathematicsfree reflection on the philosophical meaning of the quantum revolution, by one of the worlds leading authorities on the subject. Mar 16, 2009 the doctrine that the world is made up of objects whose existence is independent of human consciousness turns out to be in conflict with quantum mechanics and with facts established by experiment. The doctrine that the world is made up of objects whose existence is independent of human consciousness turns out to be in conflict with quantum mechanics and with facts established by experiment. D espagnat, 87, is a professor emeritus of theoretical.
Bernard despagnat is a theoretical physicist, philosopher and winner of the templeton prize 2009. Bernard d espagnat said it and as far as i know he is a well respected phsicist. Bernard despagnat 1976 conceptual foundation of quantum mechanics 2nd ed from phy 530 at northern arizona university. Slowly, thoughtfully and in great depth, he carefully assesses the credibility of both alternative physical theories as well as their implications for the correlative philosophy. Given a set s with three subsets, j, k, and l, the following holds. Bernard d espagnat, born august 22, 1921, fourmagnac, francedied august 1, 2015, paris, french physicist and philosopher whose research into the philosophical foundations of quantum physics addressed the conflict between the realist and instrumentalist views of the results of quantum mechanicsthat is, whether they reflect underlying physical reality or are merely rules for predicting the outcomes of experiments. Bernard despagnat 22 august 1921 1 august 2015, after spending time at the ecole polytechnique and a few years at the french national centre for scientific research cnrs with stints abroad, contributed to the creation of the theoretical physics research group at cern geneva and conducted research in elementary particles physics.
The wignerdespagnat inequality is a basic result of set theory. The theory of the quantum world proceedings of the 25th solvay conference on physics. In this largely nontechnical book, eminent physicists and philosophers address the philosophical impact of recent advances in quantum physics. Science cannot fully describe reality, says templeton. In a widely read 1979 article in scientific american, the quantum theory and reality, dr. On physics and philosophy princeton university press. He conclusively argues that features of quantum mechanicsparticularly the uncertainty principle, the nonlocality exhibited by entangled systems, and the measurement problemrevolutionize. D espagnat presents an objective account of the main guiding principles of contemporary physicsin particular, quantum mechanicsfollowed by a look at just what. His death was announced by the john templeton foundation. Wignerdespagnat inequality is partially named after him.
Knowledge, duration and the quantum world bernard d espagnat contemporary physics, especially quantum theory, has raised profound questions about the relationship between the methods of science and the reality these methods seek to investigate. Ac cording to this view the quantum theory is concerned only with observable phe158 by bernard d espagnat nomena the observed position of the pointer and not with any underlying physical state the real position of the electron. While serving as assistant professor at the university of parisorsay, i spent half of my working time at cern in geneva. Bernard d espagnat, who has died aged 93, was a french physicist and philosopher of science who in 2009 won the. Bernard d espagnat, a french physicist and philosopher whose writings explored the philosophical implications of the paradoxical laws that govern the subatomic realm, died on aug. Contrary to classical physics, which was strongly objective. After the editors introduction, the next chapter reveals the strangeness of quantum mechanics and the subsequent discussions examine our notion of reality. Veiled reality bernard despagnat this long book 450 pages is concerned with conceptual issues around measurement in quantum mechanics. Bernard despagnat, quantum physics and reality philpapers. Princeton university press, 2006, 503 pages, isbn 0691119643 published in studies in history and philosophy of modern physics 38b 2007, pp. Bernard despagnat 22 august 1921 1 august 2015 was a french theoretical physicist. Contemporary physics, especially quantum theory, has raised profound questions about the relationship between the methods of science and the reality these methods seek to investigate. Aug 18, 2015 the debt we all owe bernard despagnat 19212015 posted on 18 august, 2015 24 august, 2015 by sadistic scribbler in consciousness, dawkins, idealism, materialism, monistic idealism, nature of reality, quantum measurement theory, quantum mechanics, the hard problem.
Bernard d espagnat 1989 cambridge university press. In this comment it is shown that this choice is forced on us by an inconsistent. Despagnat presents an objective account of the main guiding principles of contemporary physicsin particular, quantum mechanicsfollowed by a look at just. He was a research physicist at the french national center for scientific research, at the fermi national accelerator laboratory in chicago, at the niels bohr. Veiled reality an analysis of presentday quantum mechanical concepts. A lifetime studying quantum mechanics has convinced bernard despagnat that the world we perceive is merely a shadow of the ultimate. Bernard d espagnat, veiled reality an analysis of present. May 04, 2018 and a thorough examination of this whole material finally leads to the view that distinguishing between empirical reality and a veiled manindependent reality yields an acceptable answer to the perplexing question of how to interpret quantum physics. In his 1979 scientific american article, the quantum theory and reality, and bestselling. According to d espagnat we must choose between nonlinear breaks in quantum state evolution and weak objectivity. Bernard d espagnat submitted to quantum nonlocality and reality 50 years of bells theorem important advancements in scientific knowledge may, not. Veiled reality offers nonspecialists, including students in physics, philosophy and the history. Bernard despagnat 1976 conceptual foundation of quantum.
535 229 483 1404 564 1168 990 772 374 1172 1359 918 9 12 1356 1074 65 165 205 851 1113 651 1565 1387 657 520 1115 564 302 1417 373 1311 218 1062 1450 1099 584 1258 805 1391 245 1160 1221 672